Conviction stands for woman in maid abuse case
KUALA LUMPUR: The housewife who abused Indonesian maid Nirmala Bonat failed in her bid to strike out her conviction by claiming that the previous judge had been tricked into finding her guilty.
The Sessions Court dismissed the application by Yim Pek Ha, 47, ruling that she had failed to prove how the maid “tricked and defrauded” the previous judge into arriving at that decision.
Judge Rohatul Akmar Abdullah agreed yesterday with the prosecution’s preliminary objection that the burden fell on the accused to prove such accusations of fraud.
Yim’s lawyer Kamsah Bakar submitted that Nirmala had brought up false issues to manipulate the prosecution into deceiving the court.
He said the maid claimed Yim hurt her in March 2004, contradicting the expert medical report that the injuries occurred later.
However, DPP Wan Shaharuddin Wan Ladin said the defence failed to provide a clear chronology or adequate information, lacking even an affidavit by the applicant.
The application also failed to state under which law the Sessions Court had authority to set aside the conviction, he added.
The court dismissed the application and ordered RM3,000 in costs paid to the prosecution.
Kamsah told reporters later that he had not received instructions from Yim’s husband Hii Ik Ting on whether or not to appeal.
Yim was charged with four counts of causing grievous hurt to Nirmala at her apartment in Villa Putera, Jalan Tun Ismail, Kuala Lumpur, in January, March and April 2004.
She was found guilty and sentenced to 18 years’ jail by the Kuala Lumpur Sessions Court on three counts of causing grievous hurt to Nirmala with a hot iron and hot water, but was acquitted on the fourth charge of causing hurt to the maid with a metal cup.
On appeal to the Kuala Lumpur High Court, her jail term was reduced to 12 years.
The High Court affirmed Yim’s conviction on the first and second charges but acquitted her of the third charge.
It also overturned an acquittal by the Sessions Court on the fourth charge.
On Oct 1, 2012, the Court of Appeal upheld the High Court decision.
Read more at http://www.thestar.com.my/news/nation/2017/08/31/conviction-stands-for-woman-in-maid-abuse-case-yim-fails-to-prove-how-nirmala-tricked-and-defrauded/#kDjVrqwf1ox0D0qf.99
Translate
Popular Posts - Last 7 days
-
Kadar jangka pendek diunjurkan kekal kukuh disokong operasi BNM Bernama 04/11/2024 Hari ini, BNM akan menawarkan dua tender repo berbalik m...
-
The King of Spain was mocked, pelted with mud and eggs by flood victims Agency 04/11/2024 07:15 MYT King Felipe VI (with an umbrella) is pr...
-
Actress Siti Saleha just wants a fuss-free wedding Read more at http://www.star2.com/people/2017/07/27/siti-saleha-marries-lutfi-azha...
-
A VIP police escort who punched a disabled e-hailing driver in the face was fined RM1,000 Police escort fined for assaulting disabled e-hai...
-
TGIF Malaysia tidak terjejas dengan penyusunan semula TGIF Inc Bernama 04/11/2024 Pemegang francais induk dan pemaju TGIF Malaysia mengesah...
-
US$3 billion development for TRX diverted into Najib's account, says judge Bernama 30/10/2024 The High Court today ordered imprisoned ex...
-
PM Anwar hadir pada perlumbaan GP Malaysia 2024 Bernama 03/11/2024 Anwar (dua, kiri) melambaikan tangan kepada para penonton ketika hadir pa...
-
US$3 billion development for TRX diverted into Najib's account, says judge Bernama 30/10/2024 19:30 MYT The High Court today ordered im...
Popular Posts - Last 30 days
-
McDonald's E. coli crisis reveals why vegetable contamination is 'harder problem' than beef Reuters 26/10/2024 Fresh produce is ...
-
Tourism Malaysia lancar jualan tengah malam untuk warga Singapura sempena Deepavali di JB Bernama 12/10/2024 Edisi pertama Jualan Tengah Mal...
-
Budget 2025: Govt allocates RM470 mil to empower women's participation in PMKS Bernama 18/10/2024 The government allocated RM470 million...
-
Kadar jangka pendek diunjurkan kekal kukuh disokong operasi BNM Bernama 04/11/2024 Hari ini, BNM akan menawarkan dua tender repo berbalik m...
-
Seorang maut, 49 lagi jatuh sakit di AS akibat jangkitan E.Coli Astro Awani 23/10/2024 CDC memaklumkan semua individu ditemu bual melaporka...
-
Paip pecah, sebahagian KL tiada air - Air Selangor Astro Awani 08/10/2024 Pengguna boleh mendapatkan maklumat berhubung gangguan bekalan air...
-
The King of Spain was mocked, pelted with mud and eggs by flood victims Agency 04/11/2024 07:15 MYT King Felipe VI (with an umbrella) is pr...
-
RUU tahanan di rumah bukan untuk ‘bebaskan’ Najib, VIP lain - Fahmi Astro Awani 25/10/2024 Menurut Fahmi, RUU itu juga untuk membantu mengu...
-
Amaran ribut petir di lapan negeri, KL dan Putrajaya hari ini Bernama 15/10/2024 Berdasarkan amaran yang dimuat naik di media sosial jabatan...
Blog Archive
-
▼
2017
(3888)
-
▼
Aug 2017
(356)
- 29th SEA Games 2017 Closing Ceremony Video in Engl...
- Malaysian PM Najib has declared Sept 4 a public ho...
- A police lance corporal was found murdered inside ...
- US embassy produces video just to congratulate Mal...
- China president's Merdeka Day message: 'Malaysia a...
- The housewife who abused Indonesian maid Nirmala B...
- 44 Rohingyas were detained by police today for hol...
- Pak Nil akan menyarungkan baju bendera Malaysia be...
- National under-22 squad coach Datuk Ong Kim Swee r...
- Live SEA Games 2017 - Final Day 30 August 2017 DIV...
- VItdaily Reviews Sri Wangsa Briyani, this video w...
- Malaysian 9 year old Adam Yoong Wins Mens Water Sk...
- Shahidan Kassim being sued for breach of contract ...
- Malaysia Lose To Thailand In a Repeat of the 2001 ...
- : A female teacher was arrested for having sex wit...
- Peminat MENGAMUK Kat KSU KBS Tiket Final Bola Suka...
- TMJ Memberi Kata Semangat kepada Pemain Malaysia d...
- Dayang Nurfaizah, dianugerahkan The BrandLaureate ...
- Miley Cyrus Ramas Payudara Nenek
- Nonny Nadirah sanggup bersumpah dia tidak ada hubu...
- Tempahan untuk nombor siri U1 hingga U9999 dibuka ...
- Perancang Perkahwinan Diserbu Tipu Para Pengantin,...
- North Korea fired a ballistic missile over Japan's...
- Woman Swallowed Whole By Opening on floor in Shen...
- Guru Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh found guilty of two ...
- All 10 bodies of the sailors who went missing were...
- Pakatan Harapan Does Not Need this right now, so s...
- LIVE ONLINE I Malaysia V Thailand Football I 29th ...
- SEA GAMES 2017 I LIVE I Channel's 1 & 2 I August 2...
- Singapore PR Loses RM1.3 million in love scam in ...
- Malaysia Reaches the 111th Gold Target for the 29t...
- Neighbour saves 3 year old girl dangling from a wi...
- On Twitter, Khairy explains why tickets for SEA Ga...
- NOW ULTRAS MALAYA TO SNUB MALAYSIA VS THAILAND FIN...
- Angry fans went out of control after failing to se...
- Indonesia have accused hosts Malaysia of cheating ...
- Athletes have shined at 29th SEA GAMES 2017 but no...
- Parts of CHERAS and Bukit Damansara will face wate...
- Dato Seri Vida fined for promoting Pamoga Health D...
- An activist was allegedly punched in the face by a...
- Ucapan Pembakar Semangat Dari TMJ (Presiden FAM) k...
- Malaysia wins landmark 100th Gold Medal through Gy...
- Live 29th SEA Games 2017 I Channel's 1 & 2 I 28 Au...
- Motorcyclist killed after being hit by Ferrari on ...
- Wonda Coffee is celebrating this year’s Internatio...
- SEA GAMES 2017 Live Online I Channel's 1&2 I 27 Au...
- Food operators in the city will not use polystyren...
- Controversial Ultras Malaya fan group cheer non st...
- Sukan Sea 2017 I Sports Minister @Khairykj motiva...
- Malaysia to meet Thailand in SEA GAMES 2-17 Footb...
- Sea Games 2017 Golden Moment - Malaysian Women's B...
- Team Malaysia I Gemuruh Suara (Lyric Video) - Ayd...
- Bangkit Bersama - Dayang Nurfaizah x Dato' Ramli M...
- RTM vows action and apologizes for flag blunder wh...
- Flag Blunder continues as 8 Out Of 11 Flags Were W...
- The son of a renowned guitarist was arrested on We...
- Live Badminton (Day 7) | 29th SEA Games 2017 I 9.0...
- 29th SEA GAMES 2017 I Live Online Channel 1 & 2 Si...
- 70 Year old man claimed trial to allegedly sodomis...
- Felda Investment Corp Chairman appointed as Chairm...
- Deadly Clashes broke out in Panchkula after a cour...
- Khairy Gets Audience With Sultan of Johor and aske...
- Shalin Zulkifli and Rafiq Ismail gave a Glorious P...
- Man jailed for fondling himself and flashing at 62...
- LIVE Basketball 🏀 Men's Semi-final match Philippi...
- A 57-year-old farmer and his three sons were sente...
- 18 roads would also be closed from 6am to 1pm from...
- Watch Tun Musa Hitam statement on Memali, and his ...
- Seorang lelaki warga Iran didenda RM2,500 dan dip...
- The new Inspector-General of Police replacing Tan ...
- Textbook leaving out Tun Mahathir as Prime Ministe...
- United States President Donald Trump met up with o...
- Public Holidays Galore in September
- 29th SEA GAMES 2017 I LIVE! Watch Both Channel 1 a...
- A 10-year-old bull elephant died after it was stru...
- Umno will hold its general assembly from Dec 5 to ...
- Video Of Malaysian Fans from all races Celebrating...
- 16 Malaysian athletes staying at Renaissance Hotel...
- Zlatan Ibrahimovic has rejoined Manchester United ...
- Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak has just wel...
- RM15.5 million invested to build 10 digital screen...
- The U.S. Navy suspended wider SAR operations for 9...
- MACC record statements on controversial RM16 milli...
- Grab celebrate Malaysia's victories at the SEA Gam...
- Simon Cowell Responds To His LIVE TV Fight with Me...
- Labo Labo Steamboat & BBQ Review by Vitdaily. - L...
- Woman strips naked after ex-hubby says he paid for...
- Two elderly men were charged again today in the Ma...
- Dutch police said they had arrested another man af...
- Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Khalid Abu Bak...
- Live Badminton Men's Team finals Malaysia v Indone...
- Two Singaporean men have been each sentenced to a ...
- The AKU 1305 (I am Boss) number plate may be the ...
- Bus driver who ferried the Malaysia hockey conting...
- The US Navy said remains found by the Malaysian na...
- President Donald Trump plans to meet Prime Ministe...
- Introduction to Samsung Galaxy Note8
- Khairul Hafiz Jantan the fastest man in South East...
- The senseless death of a teenage girl who was run ...
- 29th SEA GAMES 2017 I Live Online 2 Channels Simul...
-
▼
Aug 2017
(356)