Translate
29 August 2018
Batu Caves Temple Paint job on staircase in viral photos may be illegal as not approved by National Heritage Department
Paint job on staircase in viral photos may be illegal
Wednesday, 29 Aug 2018
by bavani m and vijenthi nair
THE colourful staircase of the iconic Batu Caves Temple that has gone viral on social media, could land the temple committee in trouble as the multimillion ringgit painting and renovation works were not sanctioned by the National Heritage Department (JWN).
This is because the Sri Subramaniar Swamy Temple located on the top of the staircase is a National Heritage site listed under the National Heritage Registry.
Nadarajah added that a few other sites were gazetted as well, including the entire compound where the yearly Thaipusam festival took place.
Activist and Sentosa assemblyman G. Gunaraj told StarMetro that JWN conservators were unhappy as permission had not been obtained from them as required under Section 40 of the National Heritage Act 2005, prior to the renovation.
“I was told that in accordance with the Act’s Section 40 requirements, the temple management must refer to the department to identify best conservation methods when there is any development or renovation work done in close proximity to a national heritage site.
“This is to ensure the integrity and legacy of the heritage structure is maintained,’’ Gunaraj said.
image: https://www.thestar.com.my/~/media/online/2018/08/28/20/37/metd_px_vibatu2_px_2.ashx?h=421&&w=300&la=en
Buckets of colourful paints were used for the steps.
His contacts in JWN had informed him that the paint works and renovation were not in harmony with the surroundings, he said, and was a “disaster” for a heritage site.
“They are disappointed that efforts to get the temple listed as a heritage site might have been in vain as the paint job could lead to the temple being delisted,’’ he said.
Gunaraj said he had read that when a heritage site fails to correspond to its “outstanding heritage” value, it could be removed from the National Heritage list.
International Council on Monuments and Sites (Icomos) Malaysia committee member Rosli Mohd Ali said: “It has been going (renovations at Batu Caves) for a long time now, but whatever they do, they must get consent from JWN.
“The temple committee cannot expect the temple to be on the heritage list and yet do whatever they like,’’ he added.
Rosli, who is also an architect, cited the historic monuments of ancient Nara, which is a Unesco heritage site in Japan, as an example.
“It included a group of Buddhist temples which had great cultural and heritage significance.
“When the government restored some of the sites which were deteriorating, it was done following stringent guidelines to ensure the integrity of the site was intact with an adequate buffer zone,” he explained.
Temple committee defends renovation
When contacted, Nadarajah said they had the necessary approvals to proceed with the renovations.
“The paint job does not require any approval. For the renovation, we had approval from Selayang Municipal Council (MPS).
“Since we are not constructing any new building, we did not need to seek approval from JWN,’’ he said.
However, MPS corporate affairs deputy director Ahmad Fauzi Ishak said there was no record of any approval given for any works in Batu Caves, in a long time.
“In fact, we are still waiting for the documents and corresponding technical reports required to legalise the structures and buildings in and around Batu Caves, which has been going on for the last five years,” he said.
Nadarajah said the renovation works on the Batu Caves ground began early last year.
image: https://www.thestar.com.my/~/media/online/2018/08/28/20/37/metd_px_vibatu2_px_1.ashx?h=413&&w=620&la=en
A view of the colourful steps at Batu Caves in the day. — Photos: S.S.KANESAN/The Star
“In preparation for the consecration ceremony on Aug 31, all 13 temples in Batu Caves underwent renovations, and this included new entrance towers, new tiles, paint and sculptures, among others.
“Experienced temple builders from India were commissioned for much of the renovation works. The temple now looks a lot like those in India, or even better.
“We have spent RM6.1mil so far but the actual cost will be revealed on the consecration day,” he said, adding that the sum was from donations.
Nadarajah said the idea for the steps’ colour scheme was mooted by his son Datuk N. Sivakumar, who also sits in the committee.
He added that the colourful steps would attract more tourists to visit the site and the renovations would give devotees a more comfortable place to pray.
Nadarajah’s claims, however, have raised concerns as MPS is still in the process of legalising many of the structures in Batu Caves which were built without going through standard approval processes.
It was also learnt that JWN’s enforcement team have been visiting the site regularly since the temple was listed as a heritage site, for monitoring purposes under Section 39 of the Act, and the temple management were repeatedly reminded to get JWN’s consent for any works carried out at the site.
The temple, also known as the cave temple, is one of 30 caves open to the public.
The cave temple has a 100m vaulted ceiling and right above the cave is an opening where one can see the sky.
The stairway is divided into sets of 17 steps by landings and a 272 flight of steps lead up to the temple.
Previously, StarMetro had reported that Batu Caves could not qualify for the Unesco World Heritage List as its current building was not in harmony with its surroundings.
Meanwhile, the JWN source said they were looking into the matter to get an explanation from the temple management to see what kind of action would be taken.
Read more at https://www.thestar.com.my/metro/metro-news/2018/08/29/paint-job-on-staircase-in-viral-photos-may-be-illegal-national-heritage-department-deems-work-a-disa/#Md2DuwLkAS2VfBUA.99
Popular Posts - Last 7 days
-
Ringgit advances as domestic optimism offsets US rate concerns Bernama 18/11/2024 Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd chief economist Dr Mohd Afzani...
-
Sugar overload: A growing threat to kidney function Bernama 16/11/2024 Approximately 3.8 mln Malaysians suffer from chronic kidney disease, ...
-
Bursa Malaysia dibuka tinggi, jejaki kenaikan di Wall Street dalam tempoh semalaman Bernama 22/11/2024 Keseluruhan pasaran adalah positif, d...
-
Warga emas maut ketika tukar tayar kereta di LKSA Astro Awani 18/11/2024 Tindakan seorang lelaki warga emas menghentikan keretanya di bahu ...
-
Bung Moktar, isteri diperintah bela diri tiga tuduhan rasuah Bernama 18/11/2024 Bung Mokhtar dan Zizie tiba di Istana Kehakiman, Putrajaya, ...
-
Malaysia to become leading hub for green investments, drive sustainable growth Astro Awani 20/11/2024 Minister of Housing and Local Governme...
-
Malaysia dipilih semula terajui Lembaga Pengarah SMIIC Bernama 20/11/2024 MITI berkata keanggotaan Malaysia dalam SMIIC telah diluluskan ol...
-
More than 800 million adults have diabetes globally, many untreated, study suggests Reuters 17/11/2024 A person receives a free blood sugar...
Popular Posts - Last 30 days
-
McDonald's E. coli crisis reveals why vegetable contamination is 'harder problem' than beef Reuters 26/10/2024 Fresh produce is ...
-
CNN CBS AP BBC US PRESIDENTIAL ELECTIONS LIVE RESULTS: https://edition.cnn.com/election/2024/results/president?elec...
-
Ringgit advances as domestic optimism offsets US rate concerns Bernama 18/11/2024 Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd chief economist Dr Mohd Afzani...
-
Kadar jangka pendek diunjurkan kekal kukuh disokong operasi BNM Bernama 04/11/2024 Hari ini, BNM akan menawarkan dua tender repo berbalik m...
-
Sugar overload: A growing threat to kidney function Bernama 16/11/2024 Approximately 3.8 mln Malaysians suffer from chronic kidney disease, ...
-
Lyia Meta, the first Malaysian singer nominated in the Grammy Awards Astro Awani 11/11/2024 Lyia Meta continues to strengthen her position...
-
TikTok gives assurance to cooperate with MCMC, BNM to address cyberbullying, scams Bernama 14/11/2024 PM Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim meeting w...
-
The King of Spain was mocked, pelted with mud and eggs by flood victims Agency 04/11/2024 07:15 MYT King Felipe VI (with an umbrella) is pr...
Blog Archive
-
▼
2018
(4100)
-
▼
Aug 2018
(420)
- Teenage sailor Fauzi Kaman Shah won the Laser 4.7 ...
- AG Appoints A Senior Lawyer and An Ex Judge as le...
- Sidang Media Penuh SPRM Tentang Tangkapan 9 orang ...
- Malaysia National Day Parade 2018 I Perbarisan da...
- Video : Malaysia Stuns India in Semi Finals To Qua...
- The National Day 2018 celebrated on Friday (Aug 31...
- Jacky Cheung fans camp out at the Quill City Mall ...
- Tun Dr. Mahathir:our aspiration for Malaysia to be...
- Azizulhasni Awang Wins Cycling Sprint Gold at Asia...
- The Yang di-Pertuan Agong cancelled the Sept 9 off...
- Putrajaya clarifies after cronyism allegation, Pet...
- A “Middle Eastern source” may have provided US$12 ...
- Putrajaya has said it is disappointed with Batu Ca...
- An unemployed man was today charged for proclaimin...
- Tabung Harapan Malaysia will cease accepting donat...
- Timbalan perdana menteri berkata beliau 'sangat ti...
- Two men were arrested in connection with the fake ...
- After 13 years, the National Day celebration will ...
- The Sales and Service Tax (SST) threshold for eate...
- The Esscom is not happy with Malaysian actor who c...
- DNA samples of the Dutch model Ivana Smit and that...
- GT Global Race (M) Sdn Bhd has issued a winding-up...
- JPJ BLacklist for those who fail to Settle DBKL su...
- Dato Seri Vidas Cryptocurrency LaVida Coin goes o...
- The mother of the late Tan Sri Jamaluddin Jarjis a...
- A Malaysian silat exponent caused an uproar after ...
- Batu Caves Temple Paint job on staircase in viral ...
- Former Malaysian External Investigation Organisati...
- MACC has arrested former DG of Research Department...
- Tottenham Hotspur romped to a 3-0 Premier League w...
- Anwar Ibrahim Bersuara Isu Beliau Dan Tun Dr Mahat...
- Ali Hamsa -KSN Replaced By Treasury secretary-gene...
- Malaysia won the coveted inter-regu sepak takraw ...
- Former MIC vice-president Tan Sri S. Balakrishnan ...
- 7 civil servants from Research Department at Prime...
- Thai Facebook users have condemned a Thai man for ...
- Husband claims police are refreshing remand order ...
- KL parents accidentally leave behind 3 year old to...
- Rafizi Ramli is allowed to contest in the PKR elec...
- Najib Razak was summoned to the Anti-Money Launder...
- Malaysian 21 Year Old Rafiq Beats South Korean Def...
- Winners and losers of sales and services tax (SST)
- "I was offered RM1.5 million if I admitted to kill...
- Former MIC VP Tan Sri Arrested by MACC for Money ...
- Full list of SST tax-exempt items are expected to ...
- The ceiling price for coarse granulated sugar and ...
- Malaysia will not allow foreigners to buy resident...
- Perhilitan ranger Ahmad Tarmizi found after almost...
- Gunman kills four at Madden 19 video game tourname...
- Just hours after a double murder shocked Penang, a...
- Anwar - The Security Offenses (Special Measures) A...
- E-Sports Fans Rejoiced After Malaysian Team placed...
- DPM Wan Azizah Speaks From The Heart At the launch...
- AG: No one bothered about the Manifesto before GE1...
- Nicol Davids wins Malaysia's second Gold Medal in ...
- AKSI Mat Rempit Lawan Arus Elak Roadblock
- Finance Minister Lim Guan Eng Says it as it is: GS...
- Cash handouts such as the 1Malaysia People’s Aid (...
- Tun Mahathir Hentam Najib, Rosmah, Jho Low
- Mat Sabu's warning to politicians who run afoul of...
- A woman walking in just her bikini bottom and a lo...
- Tun Dr Mahathir to those from previous administra...
- Tun Dr Mahathir needs the Council of Eminent Perso...
- Saifuddin Abdullah plays the role of A Diplomat wh...
- Escorts must be moonlighting, if Hishammuddin’s es...
- Referee gives Japan highly debatable Penalty in th...
- Malaysia is assured of a gold medal in the women's...
- Group of 20 Transgenders cite Hindu religious righ...
- Police Inspector Muhd Aidil Ja’afar became an Inte...
- 10 out of 13 judges from the apex court, are due t...
- Dr Muhammed Abdul Khalid appointed the Economic Ad...
- Yang di-Pertuan Agong will not be conferring any t...
- The ceiling of the Bukit Raja toll plaza in Klang ...
- 23-year-old babysitter arrested to facilitate inve...
- 3 Southeast Asians, including a Malaysian Mohamad ...
- THE Sessions Court has issued warrants of arrest f...
- Several main roads in Putrajaya will be closed and...
- Three masked men stormed into a couple's home in K...
- 2018 Royal Floria Putrajaya evolved from tourism p...
- Penampilan Via Vallen di Sukan Asia 2018 Berhasil ...
- Najib Razak's Loyalist In 1MDB Scandal Tan Sri Lod...
- Admiralty Court grants the selling of superyacht E...
- Gambar & Video Bogel Anak Pelakon Terkenal Che Ta ...
- Jho Low and his father Tan Sri (Larry) Low Hock Pe...
- Official Theme Song Asian Games 2018 Performed by:...
- Police have identified the mastermind involved in ...
- Singapore Airlines (SIA) pilot has died after a mo...
- Man was nabbed by Indonesian police for sexual as...
- THE Inland Revenue Board is being investigated for...
- Cosmetics millionaire Datuk Seri Vida, has launche...
- RM1,111,111 for 'Malaysia 1' number plate
- Tun Dr Mahathir " People Who Signed Contracts With...
- PM Tun Dr Mahathir questiones the need for a wall ...
- Police smashed a drug smuggling and distribution s...
- On Wednesday Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Muhammad...
- A superbiker died after being dragged two kilometr...
- Heavy security, secrecy surrounds Musa Aman's VVIP...
- Malaysian student’s delightful rendezvous with Dr ...
- Bila Menteri Pertahanan Pi Cucok Duit Kat Maybank
- Nga kor Ming Menbongkarkan MAPS mengalami kerugian...
-
▼
Aug 2018
(420)