Saudi Suggests Pilgrims At Fault Over Hajj Deaths, Iran Angry
MINA: Saudi Arabia on Friday suggested pilgrims ignoring crowd control rules bore some blame for a crush that killed over 700 people at the hajj pilgrimage in the annual event's worst disaster for 25 years.
The kingdom's regional rival Iran expressed outrage at the deaths of 131 of its nationals at the world's largest annual gathering of people, and politicians in Tehran suggested Riyadh was incapable of managing the event.
Hundreds of demonstrators protested in the Iranian capital, chanting "Death to the Saudi dynasty".
With pilgrims frantically searching for missing compatriots and photographs of piles of the dead circulating on social media, the tragedy haunted many on the hajj a day on.
"There were layers of bodies, maybe three layers," said one witness who asked not to be named. "Some people were alive under the pile of bodies and were trying to climb up but in vain, because their strength failed and they dropped dead.
"I felt helpless not to be able to save people. I saw them dying in front of my eyes," he told Reuters.
An Algerian pilgrim told Algeria's al-Shurouk television: "We saw death: People were stepping over the mutilated bodies in front of you, four or five on top of each other."
Saudi King Salman ordered a review of hajj plans, and Health Minister Khalid al-Falih said an investigation would be conducted rapidly and a final toll of dead and wounded calculated.
At least 863 pilgrims were injured in the disaster, in which two big groups of pilgrims collided at a crossroads in Mina, a few km (miles) east of Makkah, on their way to performing the "Stoning of the Devil" ritual at Jamarat.
The stampede "was perhaps because some pilgrims moved without following instructions by the relevant authorities," the minister said in a statement.
The kingdom's critics were likely to see the statement as an attempt to deflect responsibility. Safety during the hajj is highly sensitive for the ruling Al Saud dynasty, which presents itself internationally as the guardian of orthodox Islam and custodian of its holiest places in Makkah and Medina.
The effort to uncover the facts and assign blame was likely to grow more acute and possibly more political.
"Catastrophe"
A pilgrim who gave his name as Abu Abdallah said security forces appeared on high alert after the deaths. "What happened is a tragedy and many people ... are terrified, but in the end we can only pursue our hajj duties," he said.
Hakim, from Morocco, said: "It is simply scary to hear how people crushed one another. More frightening is that we do not know how it happened."
The Saudi civil defence service reported on Twitter that a fire had occurred in three storage facilities in Makkah's al-Maaseem neighbourhood, and 10 fire and rescue units were in attendance. No further details were immediately available.
Iran's President Hassan Rouhani, in New York to attend the U.N. General Assembly, echoed Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in blaming Saudi Arabia for the incident.
"I ask the Saudi Arabian government to take responsibility for this catastrophe and fulfil its legal and Islamic duties in this regard," Rouhani said in a statement.
Iranian state television said the demonstrators in Tehran were showing their anger at "Saudi incapability and incompetence to run the hajj".
"The world will not accept excuses like the weather was hot or the pilgrims were disorganised," Tehran Friday prayer leader Mohammed Emami-Kashani was quoted as saying by Fars news agency.
Iran's deputy Foreign Minister Hossein Amir Abdollahian also called "Riyadh's negligence inexcusable" and announced a committee has been established to look into the incident.
Iranian pilgrims who survived described Saudi's response "too little, too late," according to Iran's state run Press TV. They said rescuers arrived two hours after the incident and started collecting dead bodies first instead of helping the injured.
Saudi Arabia's Interior Ministry spokesman Major General Mansour Turki was quoted in Saudi media on Friday as saying the security forces had immediately responded and begun to rescue those who fell in the crush.
"This year's hajj ceremony was disorganised as the Saudi government had hired young and inexperienced people," Saeed Ohadi, Head of Iran's hajj and pilgrimage organisation told Iran's state broadcaster in a live interview from Mecca.
Speaking in New York, Pope Francis expressed "my sentiments of closeness" with Muslims after the tragedy. U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and the United States offered condolences.
Former Iraqi Prime minister Nuri al-Maliki, an ally of Iran and foe of Riyadh, said the incident was "proof of the incompetence of the organisers". He said the hajj should be placed under the authority of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, the world's largest Muslim organisation.
- Reuters
MINA: Saudi Arabia on Friday suggested pilgrims ignoring crowd control rules bore some blame for a crush that killed over 700 people at the hajj pilgrimage in the annual event's worst disaster for 25 years.
The kingdom's regional rival Iran expressed outrage at the deaths of 131 of its nationals at the world's largest annual gathering of people, and politicians in Tehran suggested Riyadh was incapable of managing the event.
Hundreds of demonstrators protested in the Iranian capital, chanting "Death to the Saudi dynasty".
With pilgrims frantically searching for missing compatriots and photographs of piles of the dead circulating on social media, the tragedy haunted many on the hajj a day on.
"There were layers of bodies, maybe three layers," said one witness who asked not to be named. "Some people were alive under the pile of bodies and were trying to climb up but in vain, because their strength failed and they dropped dead.
"I felt helpless not to be able to save people. I saw them dying in front of my eyes," he told Reuters.
An Algerian pilgrim told Algeria's al-Shurouk television: "We saw death: People were stepping over the mutilated bodies in front of you, four or five on top of each other."
Saudi King Salman ordered a review of hajj plans, and Health Minister Khalid al-Falih said an investigation would be conducted rapidly and a final toll of dead and wounded calculated.
At least 863 pilgrims were injured in the disaster, in which two big groups of pilgrims collided at a crossroads in Mina, a few km (miles) east of Makkah, on their way to performing the "Stoning of the Devil" ritual at Jamarat.
The stampede "was perhaps because some pilgrims moved without following instructions by the relevant authorities," the minister said in a statement.
The kingdom's critics were likely to see the statement as an attempt to deflect responsibility. Safety during the hajj is highly sensitive for the ruling Al Saud dynasty, which presents itself internationally as the guardian of orthodox Islam and custodian of its holiest places in Makkah and Medina.
The effort to uncover the facts and assign blame was likely to grow more acute and possibly more political.
"Catastrophe"
A pilgrim who gave his name as Abu Abdallah said security forces appeared on high alert after the deaths. "What happened is a tragedy and many people ... are terrified, but in the end we can only pursue our hajj duties," he said.
Hakim, from Morocco, said: "It is simply scary to hear how people crushed one another. More frightening is that we do not know how it happened."
The Saudi civil defence service reported on Twitter that a fire had occurred in three storage facilities in Makkah's al-Maaseem neighbourhood, and 10 fire and rescue units were in attendance. No further details were immediately available.
Iran's President Hassan Rouhani, in New York to attend the U.N. General Assembly, echoed Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in blaming Saudi Arabia for the incident.
"I ask the Saudi Arabian government to take responsibility for this catastrophe and fulfil its legal and Islamic duties in this regard," Rouhani said in a statement.
Iranian state television said the demonstrators in Tehran were showing their anger at "Saudi incapability and incompetence to run the hajj".
"The world will not accept excuses like the weather was hot or the pilgrims were disorganised," Tehran Friday prayer leader Mohammed Emami-Kashani was quoted as saying by Fars news agency.
Iran's deputy Foreign Minister Hossein Amir Abdollahian also called "Riyadh's negligence inexcusable" and announced a committee has been established to look into the incident.
Iranian pilgrims who survived described Saudi's response "too little, too late," according to Iran's state run Press TV. They said rescuers arrived two hours after the incident and started collecting dead bodies first instead of helping the injured.
Saudi Arabia's Interior Ministry spokesman Major General Mansour Turki was quoted in Saudi media on Friday as saying the security forces had immediately responded and begun to rescue those who fell in the crush.
"This year's hajj ceremony was disorganised as the Saudi government had hired young and inexperienced people," Saeed Ohadi, Head of Iran's hajj and pilgrimage organisation told Iran's state broadcaster in a live interview from Mecca.
Speaking in New York, Pope Francis expressed "my sentiments of closeness" with Muslims after the tragedy. U.N. Secretary General Ban Ki-moon and the United States offered condolences.
Former Iraqi Prime minister Nuri al-Maliki, an ally of Iran and foe of Riyadh, said the incident was "proof of the incompetence of the organisers". He said the hajj should be placed under the authority of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, the world's largest Muslim organisation.
- Reuters
.jpg)
