Translate
21 October 2019
Ex-O&G employee wins RM540,000 for unfair dismissal
Ex-O&G employee wins RM540,000 for unfair dismissal
V Anbalagan
-October 21, 2019 8:08 AM
File pic.
KUALA LUMPUR: A former employee of a petroleum company was awarded compensation of RM540,000 after the Industrial Court ruled that her dismissal on grounds of being a contract employee was wrongly conceived.
Industrial Court chairman Bernard John Kanny said after considering the evidence at hand that Nor Aini Sabil was in fact a permanent employee of Murphy Sarawak Oil Co Ltd.
“The dismissal of the claimant on grounds of retrenchment was unfounded as she was a permanent staff,” he said in his 30-page award released last week.
Nor Aini was informed by her employer in July 2015 that she would be retrenched on grounds of redundancy. She was urged to accept a mutual separation agreement.
Her last drawn monthly basic salary was RM14,929, with a fixed allowance of RM1,200.
Kanny said Nor Aini, represented by S Muhendran and Chong Wan Loo, was employed as a document control coordinator for four years.
She subsequently worked as a project coordinator for three years and a maintenance contract supervisor for three and a half years from 2005.
“It is clear to this court that the employment status of the claimant was an ordinary employment that was dressed up in the form of a succession of fixed-term contracts,” Kanny said.
He said he found that each renewal had taken place automatically before the expiration of contract with no break in Nor Aini’s service.
“The rendering of service by the claimant to the business was in no manner interrupted,” he added.
He also noted that Nor Aini was granted pilgrimage leave, a benefit only available to permanent employees, in particular those who have served for five continuous years.
He said the court found no reduction, diminution or cessation of Nor Aini’s responsibilities or functions.
He said her duties were carried out by three junior employees after her termination, which was done in bad faith.
“There was no redundancy which justified the claimant’s dismissal,” he said, adding that the retrenchment was done in an unfair manner.
Kanny said in carrying out retrenchment exercises, employers must comply with the “last in, first out” principle of selection.
He said although Nor Aini had pleaded for reinstatement with full back wages, the court had decided that this was not appropriate to the circumstances of the case.
Nor Aini was awarded back wages and compensation amounting to RM541,068.29 in lieu of reinstatement, following the deduction of RM7,317.71 paid to her in retrenchment benefits.
Popular Posts - Last 7 days
-
Maybank Singapore withdraws lawsuit against NFC chairman, children over housing loans Bernama Julai 12, 2022 Maybank Singapore Limited has...
-
Kedah MB: ECK no longer part of Kulim airport project Bernama Julai 13, 2022 Muhammad Sanusi announced that the ECK Group of Companies (EC...
-
No 10m Platform Medal But Pandelela & Dhabitah Are More Determined Than Ever Our hearts nearly leaped out of our chests when we heard...
-
My duty and role as director exist only in name - SRC former director Bernama Mac 27, 2024 Datuk Shahrol Azral Ibrahim Halmi said absolute ...
-
Mitsubishi Triton Guna Siren Adalah Milik PDRM Kenderaan pacuan empat roda yang menggunakan siren dan lampu kecemasan bagi mendapatkan ...
-
King presents appointment letters to four new envoys Bernama Julai 12, 2022 His Majesty presenting the letter of appointment to M'sian...
-
Seven million Malaysians yet to take booster dose against COVID-19 - PM Bernama Julai 11, 2022 Prime Minister Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaako...
-
Nurjiwa & PRIHATIN Present Donations To Orphans, Single Mothers and Veteran Artist at Iftar FunctionNurjiwa Prihatin's Iftar was held on Tuesday at Royale Chulan Kuala Lumpur. At this event, Yayasan Prihatin Nasional and Yayasan Nurjiw...
-
Wan Saiful confirms he is no longer PTPTN chairman Bernama Julai 12, 2022 Bersatu Information chief Datuk Wan Saiful Wan Jan today confirm...
Popular Posts - Last 30 days
-
A man was stabbed to death by his lover who was a part-time model in an incident at a condominium unit in Kota Kemuning here on Monday. It i...
-
Paris court grants Malaysia's application to suspend claims by purported heirs of Sultan Jamalul Kiram II Bernama Julai 13, 2022 Dr Wa...
-
Maybank Singapore withdraws lawsuit against NFC chairman, children over housing loans Bernama Julai 12, 2022 Maybank Singapore Limited has...
-
Motorcycle crash: Couple accept casualties to twin children as fate Bernama Julai 17, 2022 A couple lost a child while another suffered se...
-
Wan Saiful confirms he is no longer PTPTN chairman Bernama Julai 12, 2022 Bersatu Information chief Datuk Wan Saiful Wan Jan today confirm...
-
Kedah MB: ECK no longer part of Kulim airport project Bernama Julai 13, 2022 Muhammad Sanusi announced that the ECK Group of Companies (EC...
-
COVID-19: New cases in Malaysia take a slight dip again Melissa Fernando ASTRO AWANI Julai 19, 2022 12:00 MYT COVID-19: New cases in Malays...
-
MH17 tragedy: Dewan Rakyat expresses condolences to families of passengers, crew Bernama Julai 18, 2022 The Dewan Rakyat today marked the ...
-
Malaysian Space Board to be fully launched early next year - Dr Adham Bernama Julai 18, 2022 The Malaysian Space Board will be fully launc...
-
Naz Empire's defamation lawsuit against Awal Ashaari to go to trial as mediation fails Bernama Julai 12, 2022 The defamation lawsuit f...
Blog Archive
-
►
2023
(3771)
- December (311)
- November (322)
- October (286)
- September (288)
- August (365)
- July (349)
- June (372)
- May (316)
- April (279)
- March (301)
- February (245)
- January (337)
-
►
2022
(4309)
- December (352)
- November (422)
- October (288)
- September (281)
- August (347)
- July (303)
- June (335)
- May (406)
- April (341)
- March (371)
- February (390)
- January (473)
-
►
2021
(9030)
- December (636)
- November (647)
- October (809)
- September (797)
- August (880)
- July (894)
- June (747)
- May (780)
- April (580)
- March (629)
- February (643)
- January (988)
-
►
2020
(6800)
- December (819)
- November (698)
- October (832)
- September (729)
- August (548)
- July (558)
- June (615)
- May (394)
- April (368)
- March (453)
- February (439)
- January (347)
-
▼
2019
(4089)
- December (411)
- November (425)
- October (375)
- September (279)
- August (397)
- July (353)
- June (326)
- May (315)
- April (266)
- March (318)
- February (293)
- January (331)
-
►
2018
(4100)
- December (305)
- November (304)
- October (357)
- September (352)
- August (420)
- July (442)
- June (366)
- May (412)
- April (343)
- March (275)
- February (233)
- January (291)
-
►
2017
(3888)
- December (268)
- November (293)
- October (352)
- September (309)
- August (356)
- July (300)
- June (319)
- May (354)
- April (316)
- March (335)
- February (306)
- January (380)
-
►
2016
(4563)
- December (331)
- November (328)
- October (378)
- September (415)
- August (404)
- July (380)
- June (310)
- May (370)
- April (430)
- March (484)
- February (355)
- January (378)
-
►
2015
(4588)
- December (402)
- November (392)
- October (393)
- September (375)
- August (450)
- July (392)
- June (456)
- May (407)
- April (408)
- March (374)
- February (262)
- January (277)