Bar wants RCI into ‘reprimand’ of senior judge in Indira case
FMT Reporters | August 20, 2018
Malaysian Bar president George Varughese says any attempt by a top judge to curtail other judges’ ability to perform their duties is a serious instance of judicial misconduct.
Court of Appeal judge Hamid Sultan Abu Backer says he was not assigned to hear cases relating to the constitution following his dissenting judgment in the M Indira Gandhi unilateral conversion case. (File pic)
PETALING JAYA: The Malaysian Bar today called for the immediate establishment of a Royal Commission of Inquiry (RCI) to investigate serious assertions of judicial misconduct.
The RCI must also recommend holistic reforms to improve and strengthen the judiciary, Bar president George Varughese said in a statement.
He said the Bar was “alarmed” over the recent revelations by Court of Appeal judge Hamid Sultan Abu Backer, which cast grave doubt on the integrity and independence of the judiciary.
During his presentation as a panellist at the Malaysian Bar’s International Malaysia Law Conference 2018 on Aug 16, Hamid said he was “severely reprimanded” by a “top judge” for his dissenting judgment in the M Indira Gandhi unilateral conversion case.
He added that he was subsequently not assigned or empanelled to hear cases relating to the Federal Constitution and public interest matters.
Varughese said any attempt by a top judge, or any other judge, to curtail the ability of other judges to exercise their autonomy in the performance of their judicial duties was an abuse of power and a serious instance of judicial misconduct.
“The reprimanding of a judge for a decision that was made based on the facts and the applicable laws, but that is not to the liking of the top judge, would undoubtedly send a warning signal to others within the judiciary to conform and toe the line.
“This would undoubtedly and unacceptably impinge on a judge’s ability to fulfil his or her duty.
“The alleged incident begs the question as to the prevalence of interference of this nature into the independence of individual judges, and whether similar pressure has been brought to bear on other judges, especially in high-profile public interest cases, and cases involving the state,” he said.
Varughese said a thorough investigation was needed to ascertain the facts and the extent of any interference in the ability of judges to make impartial decisions.
Measures must also be put in place to ensure that no coercion, influence or threat is ever brought to bear on any judge, he said.
“Judicial independence is sacrosanct, and forms the cornerstone of a fair and impartial judiciary.
“The spectre of judgments being tainted by undue pressure is very troubling.
“It severely undermines public confidence in the judiciary, which has for some time been a matter of immense concern to the Malaysian Bar and the public.”
Varughese said the incident also unfairly cast aspersions on the integrity and reputation of all past and current office bearers of the judiciary and Federal Court judges, and on the conscientious and scrupulous work of many good judges.
Hence, he said, it was imperative that an RCI into the judiciary be established without delay.
He said it should leave no stone unturned in carrying out its investigations and making recommendations in order to stamp out improper practices, and for the much-needed reform of the judiciary.
Translate
Popular Posts - Last 7 days
-
Bekas CEO 1MDB bukan saksi yang boleh dipercayai - Peguam Najib Bernama 30/09/2024 Wan Azwan Aiman, yang mewakili Najib, berkata saksi pend...
-
Ringgit diniaga kukuh pada paras 4.1235 berbanding dolar AS Bernama 27/09/2024 Ringgit meningkat semula berbanding dolar Amerika Syarikat p...
-
Bursa Malaysia catat sedikit penurunan selepas kenaikan awal Bernama 30/09/2024 Pada 9.15 pagi, FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI (FBM KLCI) merosot...
-
Polis buru penunggang motosikal ragut rantai di Setia Alam Afiezy Azaman 01/10/2024 Perbuatan suspek itu dirakam 'dashcam' milik ken...
-
Lebih 300,000 rumah mampu milik dibina setakat Jun Bernama 30/09/2024 PR1MA memiliki 88 projek di seluruh negara menerusi pelbagai fasa pemb...
-
No more single-use plastic bags at 20 retail chains from Oct 1 - Nga Bernama 26/09/2024 From Oct 1, 20 hypermarkets, supermarkets, convenie...
-
Naomi Campbell banned as charity trustee after probe finds misconduct Bernama 27/09/2024 British supermodel Naomi Campbell has been disquali...
-
Lima produk kosmetik dikesan mengandungi racun - KKM Bernama 30/09/2024 Penggunaan produk yang mengandungi bahan tersebut tanpa pengawasan ...
-
Felda mahu pupuk hubungan perniagaan Malaysia dan Indonesia Bernama 01/10/2024 Ahmad Shabery semasa Mesyuarat Kerja Kebangsaan KEIND kali k...
-
'Orang kuat' urus aliran tunai GISB, isteri disambung reman Sinar Harian 29/09/2024 Individu disyaki berperanan sebagai pengendali ...
Popular Posts - Last 30 days
-
Malaysia COVID-19 cases soar above 5k Melissa Fernando ASRTRO AWANI Julai 16, 2022 = Malaysia COVID-19 cases soar above 5k There were eigh...
-
37 individuals remanded in probe into misappropriation of PenjanaKerjaya funds Bernama Julai 15, 2022 MACC today remanded 37 individuals to...
-
All Malaysian pilgrims complete haj pilgrimage Bernama Julai 12, 2022 All 14,305 Malaysian pilgrims have completed the Haj without any unt...
-
BBQ Buffet Buy 2 Free 1 Experience a sumptuous BBQ Steamboat Buffet Dinner with Royale Chulan's exclusive "Buy 2 Free 1&qu...
-
Bekas CEO 1MDB bukan saksi yang boleh dipercayai - Peguam Najib Bernama 30/09/2024 Wan Azwan Aiman, yang mewakili Najib, berkata saksi pend...
-
Wan Saiful trial: Prosecution witness says RM38,160 deposited into Sinar Karangkraf account Bernama 18/09/2024 Former Bersatu Information c...
-
Twitter sues Elon Musk to hold him to $44 billion deal Reuters Julai 13, 2022 The lawsuit accused Musk of "a long list" of viola...
-
Evening Standard Otter attack in Malaysia leaves woman bloodied and unable to stand EVENING STANDARD 12 September 2024 Otter attack in Mal...
-
Ringgit diniaga kukuh pada paras 4.1235 berbanding dolar AS Bernama 27/09/2024 Ringgit meningkat semula berbanding dolar Amerika Syarikat p...
Blog Archive
-
▼
2018
(4100)
-
▼
Aug 2018
(420)
- Teenage sailor Fauzi Kaman Shah won the Laser 4.7 ...
- AG Appoints A Senior Lawyer and An Ex Judge as le...
- Sidang Media Penuh SPRM Tentang Tangkapan 9 orang ...
- Malaysia National Day Parade 2018 I Perbarisan da...
- Video : Malaysia Stuns India in Semi Finals To Qua...
- The National Day 2018 celebrated on Friday (Aug 31...
- Jacky Cheung fans camp out at the Quill City Mall ...
- Tun Dr. Mahathir:our aspiration for Malaysia to be...
- Azizulhasni Awang Wins Cycling Sprint Gold at Asia...
- The Yang di-Pertuan Agong cancelled the Sept 9 off...
- Putrajaya clarifies after cronyism allegation, Pet...
- A “Middle Eastern source” may have provided US$12 ...
- Putrajaya has said it is disappointed with Batu Ca...
- An unemployed man was today charged for proclaimin...
- Tabung Harapan Malaysia will cease accepting donat...
- Timbalan perdana menteri berkata beliau 'sangat ti...
- Two men were arrested in connection with the fake ...
- After 13 years, the National Day celebration will ...
- The Sales and Service Tax (SST) threshold for eate...
- The Esscom is not happy with Malaysian actor who c...
- DNA samples of the Dutch model Ivana Smit and that...
- GT Global Race (M) Sdn Bhd has issued a winding-up...
- JPJ BLacklist for those who fail to Settle DBKL su...
- Dato Seri Vidas Cryptocurrency LaVida Coin goes o...
- The mother of the late Tan Sri Jamaluddin Jarjis a...
- A Malaysian silat exponent caused an uproar after ...
- Batu Caves Temple Paint job on staircase in viral ...
- Former Malaysian External Investigation Organisati...
- MACC has arrested former DG of Research Department...
- Tottenham Hotspur romped to a 3-0 Premier League w...
- Anwar Ibrahim Bersuara Isu Beliau Dan Tun Dr Mahat...
- Ali Hamsa -KSN Replaced By Treasury secretary-gene...
- Malaysia won the coveted inter-regu sepak takraw ...
- Former MIC vice-president Tan Sri S. Balakrishnan ...
- 7 civil servants from Research Department at Prime...
- Thai Facebook users have condemned a Thai man for ...
- Husband claims police are refreshing remand order ...
- KL parents accidentally leave behind 3 year old to...
- Rafizi Ramli is allowed to contest in the PKR elec...
- Najib Razak was summoned to the Anti-Money Launder...
- Malaysian 21 Year Old Rafiq Beats South Korean Def...
- Winners and losers of sales and services tax (SST)
- "I was offered RM1.5 million if I admitted to kill...
- Former MIC VP Tan Sri Arrested by MACC for Money ...
- Full list of SST tax-exempt items are expected to ...
- The ceiling price for coarse granulated sugar and ...
- Malaysia will not allow foreigners to buy resident...
- Perhilitan ranger Ahmad Tarmizi found after almost...
- Gunman kills four at Madden 19 video game tourname...
- Just hours after a double murder shocked Penang, a...
- Anwar - The Security Offenses (Special Measures) A...
- E-Sports Fans Rejoiced After Malaysian Team placed...
- DPM Wan Azizah Speaks From The Heart At the launch...
- AG: No one bothered about the Manifesto before GE1...
- Nicol Davids wins Malaysia's second Gold Medal in ...
- AKSI Mat Rempit Lawan Arus Elak Roadblock
- Finance Minister Lim Guan Eng Says it as it is: GS...
- Cash handouts such as the 1Malaysia People’s Aid (...
- Tun Mahathir Hentam Najib, Rosmah, Jho Low
- Mat Sabu's warning to politicians who run afoul of...
- A woman walking in just her bikini bottom and a lo...
- Tun Dr Mahathir to those from previous administra...
- Tun Dr Mahathir needs the Council of Eminent Perso...
- Saifuddin Abdullah plays the role of A Diplomat wh...
- Escorts must be moonlighting, if Hishammuddin’s es...
- Referee gives Japan highly debatable Penalty in th...
- Malaysia is assured of a gold medal in the women's...
- Group of 20 Transgenders cite Hindu religious righ...
- Police Inspector Muhd Aidil Ja’afar became an Inte...
- 10 out of 13 judges from the apex court, are due t...
- Dr Muhammed Abdul Khalid appointed the Economic Ad...
- Yang di-Pertuan Agong will not be conferring any t...
- The ceiling of the Bukit Raja toll plaza in Klang ...
- 23-year-old babysitter arrested to facilitate inve...
- 3 Southeast Asians, including a Malaysian Mohamad ...
- THE Sessions Court has issued warrants of arrest f...
- Several main roads in Putrajaya will be closed and...
- Three masked men stormed into a couple's home in K...
- 2018 Royal Floria Putrajaya evolved from tourism p...
- Penampilan Via Vallen di Sukan Asia 2018 Berhasil ...
- Najib Razak's Loyalist In 1MDB Scandal Tan Sri Lod...
- Admiralty Court grants the selling of superyacht E...
- Gambar & Video Bogel Anak Pelakon Terkenal Che Ta ...
- Jho Low and his father Tan Sri (Larry) Low Hock Pe...
- Official Theme Song Asian Games 2018 Performed by:...
- Police have identified the mastermind involved in ...
- Singapore Airlines (SIA) pilot has died after a mo...
- Man was nabbed by Indonesian police for sexual as...
- THE Inland Revenue Board is being investigated for...
- Cosmetics millionaire Datuk Seri Vida, has launche...
- RM1,111,111 for 'Malaysia 1' number plate
- Tun Dr Mahathir " People Who Signed Contracts With...
- PM Tun Dr Mahathir questiones the need for a wall ...
- Police smashed a drug smuggling and distribution s...
- On Wednesday Yang di-Pertuan Agong Sultan Muhammad...
- A superbiker died after being dragged two kilometr...
- Heavy security, secrecy surrounds Musa Aman's VVIP...
- Malaysian student’s delightful rendezvous with Dr ...
- Bila Menteri Pertahanan Pi Cucok Duit Kat Maybank
- Nga kor Ming Menbongkarkan MAPS mengalami kerugian...
-
▼
Aug 2018
(420)