Translate
13 February 2020
The Court of Appeal today quashed the government’s ban on three books on Islam in 2017, in a blow to home ministry's power
Appeals court quashes home ministry’s ban on 3 books on Islam
FMT Reporters
-February 13, 2020 3:47 PM
126Shares
101
16
The three books banned by the Malaysian government in 2017.
PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal today quashed the government’s ban on three books published by Islamic Renaissance Front (IRF), in a decision seen as a blow to the home ministry’s powers.
In a unanimous decision, judges Abdul Karim Abdul Jalil, Nor Bee Ariffin and Abu Bakar Jais allowed the appeal by the group to lift the ban on the books.
The books are “Islam Tanpa Keekstreman: Berhujah Untuk Kebebasan”, a translation of Turkish academic Mustafa Akyol’s “Islam without Extremes: A Muslim Case for Liberty”, as well as two volumes of IRF’s Wacana Pemikiran Reformis series. They were published in 2012, 2014 and 2016.
The home ministry’s order to ban the book was gazetted on Sept 6, 2017 under the Printing, Presses and Publications (PPP) Regulation which, among others allows the authorities to prohibit the printing, circulation and possession of printed materials.
The High Court had upheld the ban in April last year, saying it is satisfied with the former home minister’s excuse in imposing the ban.
“It was based on his own opinion after taking into account the opinions of experts. The contents of the book are likely to be prejudicial to public order and interest and likely to alarm public opinion,” judge Nordin Hassan had said.IRF director Dr Ahmad Farouk Musa.
IRF director Dr Ahmad Farouk Musa welcomed today’s verdict, saying the court has fulfilled its role as “the last bastion for the protection of freedom of expression”
“The court agrees to the Counsel arguments that it has the power to protect this fundamental liberty,” he told FMT.
He said while freedom is not absolute, it must be shown and proven that such a freedom had caused disruption of the public order.
“It should no be based simply on the whims and fancy of the minister of home affairs,” said Farouk.
“We also have the right to be heard and the decision should not be based just on the advice of Jakim while denying us our right tone heard,” he said, referring to the Department of Islamic Development Malaysia.
Farouk said that the court accepted that unless there is an express provision ousting the right, there is a right to be heard arising out of the requirements of natural justice.
He said the Printing Presses and Publications Act 1984 had not expressly ousted the right to be heard.
“The minister, having made the order without hearing the appellant, had acted in breach of the requirements of natural justice,” he added.
Popular Posts - Last 7 days
-
Ringgit diniaga kukuh pada paras 4.1235 berbanding dolar AS Bernama 27/09/2024 Ringgit meningkat semula berbanding dolar Amerika Syarikat p...
-
No more single-use plastic bags at 20 retail chains from Oct 1 - Nga Bernama 26/09/2024 From Oct 1, 20 hypermarkets, supermarkets, convenie...
-
AirAsia to add 2,000 weekly flights, 150,000 seats across 40 key routes by year-end Bernama 23/09/2024 AirAsia is expanding its domestic co...
-
Tipu pelaburan lebih RM85 juta: Bekas perunding syarikat kewangan diperintah bela diri Bernama 23/09/2024 Mahkamah menetapkan tiga hari mul...
-
Taasub melampau, pengikut GISB rela dianiaya dan jadi mangsa penderaan Bernama 26/09/2024 Razarudin berkata mereka tiada kemampuan untuk me...
-
Naomi Campbell banned as charity trustee after probe finds misconduct Bernama 27/09/2024 British supermodel Naomi Campbell has been disquali...
-
SSM siasat GISB, pendaftaran syarikat boleh dibatal jika langgar peraturan Abd Razak Mohd Ali 24/09/2024 Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali, berkata SS...
-
NUJ bimbang keputusan Mahkamah Persekutuan halang pelaporan penyiasatan Pia Ernadya 25/09/2024 NUJ komited untuk mempertahankan kebebasan m...
Popular Posts - Last 30 days
-
Malaysia COVID-19 cases soar above 5k Melissa Fernando ASRTRO AWANI Julai 16, 2022 = Malaysia COVID-19 cases soar above 5k There were eigh...
-
37 individuals remanded in probe into misappropriation of PenjanaKerjaya funds Bernama Julai 15, 2022 MACC today remanded 37 individuals to...
-
Twitter sues Elon Musk to hold him to $44 billion deal Reuters Julai 13, 2022 The lawsuit accused Musk of "a long list" of viola...
-
All Malaysian pilgrims complete haj pilgrimage Bernama Julai 12, 2022 All 14,305 Malaysian pilgrims have completed the Haj without any unt...
-
BBQ Buffet Buy 2 Free 1 Experience a sumptuous BBQ Steamboat Buffet Dinner with Royale Chulan's exclusive "Buy 2 Free 1&qu...
-
Wan Saiful trial: Prosecution witness says RM38,160 deposited into Sinar Karangkraf account Bernama 18/09/2024 Former Bersatu Information c...
-
Shahrol Azral transferred 1MDB money to Jho Low's company twice - Najib's lawyer Named 02/09/2024 Datuk Shahrol Azral Ibrahim Halmi...
-
Evening Standard Otter attack in Malaysia leaves woman bloodied and unable to stand EVENING STANDARD 12 September 2024 Otter attack in Mal...
-
CIMB recorded a net profit of RM3.9 billion in 6 months ASTRO AWANI 31/08/2024 Novan said CIMB's achievements were supported by the tru...
Blog Archive
-
►
2024
(3029)
- September (345)
- August (356)
- July (273)
- June (329)
- May (352)
- April (317)
- March (342)
- February (352)
- January (363)
-
►
2023
(3771)
- December (311)
- November (322)
- October (286)
- September (288)
- August (365)
- July (349)
- June (372)
- May (316)
- April (279)
- March (301)
- February (245)
- January (337)
-
►
2022
(4309)
- December (352)
- November (422)
- October (288)
- September (281)
- August (347)
- July (303)
- June (335)
- May (406)
- April (341)
- March (371)
- February (390)
- January (473)
-
►
2021
(9030)
- December (636)
- November (647)
- October (809)
- September (797)
- August (880)
- July (894)
- June (747)
- May (780)
- April (580)
- March (629)
- February (643)
- January (988)
-
▼
2020
(6800)
- December (819)
- November (698)
- October (832)
- September (729)
- August (548)
- July (558)
- June (615)
- May (394)
- April (368)
- March (453)
- February (439)
- January (347)
-
►
2019
(4089)
- December (411)
- November (425)
- October (375)
- September (279)
- August (397)
- July (353)
- June (326)
- May (315)
- April (266)
- March (318)
- February (293)
- January (331)
-
►
2018
(4100)
- December (305)
- November (304)
- October (357)
- September (352)
- August (420)
- July (442)
- June (366)
- May (412)
- April (343)
- March (275)
- February (233)
- January (291)
-
►
2017
(3888)
- December (268)
- November (293)
- October (352)
- September (309)
- August (356)
- July (300)
- June (319)
- May (354)
- April (316)
- March (335)
- February (306)
- January (380)
-
►
2016
(4563)
- December (331)
- November (328)
- October (378)
- September (415)
- August (404)
- July (380)
- June (310)
- May (370)
- April (430)
- March (484)
- February (355)
- January (378)
-
►
2015
(4588)
- December (402)
- November (392)
- October (393)
- September (375)
- August (450)
- July (392)
- June (456)
- May (407)
- April (408)
- March (374)
- February (262)
- January (277)