Translate
21 April 2019
Unbecoming and adversarial” for lawyers of the Housing and Local Government Ministry to call in its own pathologist to scrutinise a report by Hospital Kuala Lumpur pathologists.
Adib inquest puzzle: Why did ministry call its own expert?
Robin Augustin
-April 21, 2019 7:43 AM
Dr Shahrom Abd Wahid was called by lawyers of the health ministry to testify at the inquest into fireman Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim’s death.
PETALING JAYA: A prominent lawyer has raised a question mark over testimony by a rival pathologist at the coroner’s inquest into the death of fireman Muhammad Adib Mohd Kassim.
Speaking to FMT, Sankara Nair said it was “unbecoming and adversarial” for lawyers of the Housing and Local Government Ministry to call in its own pathologist, Dr Shahrom Abd Wahid, to scrutinise a report by Hospital Kuala Lumpur pathologists. The hospital comes under the purview of the Health Ministry.
“This is an inquest and the HKL pathologists are the accredited ones in all inquests and trials in Malaysia,” said Nair, who has been involved in the Royal Commission of Inquiries into Anwar Ibrahim’s black eye, Teoh Beng Hock’s death and the inquest into the death of Dutch model Ivana Smit.
“Other ministries have no business in dealing with pathologists to oppose HKL, it defies logic that another ministry’s lawyer seems to not want to rely on or accept a report by HKL’s pathologist.”
Shahrom had testified that it was “not likely” for Adib to come out from the reversing Emergency Medical Rescue Service van, in an attempt to escape a riot taking place outside the Sri Maha Mariamman temple in Subang Jaya on Nov 27 last year.
Doctors of Hospital Kuala Lumpur had testified earlier that they believed Adib had stepped out from the front passenger seat and there were no injuries to suggest the late fireman was assaulted, as speculated.
Nair and another lawyer, N Sivananthan questioned the motive behind the ministry’s calling its own pathologist to testify.
“It is very strange that the ministry called in someone who was not involved in the autopsy or the inquest, to begin with,” Sivananthan told FMT.
He said it would appear that the ministry was not happy with the views given by HKL’s pathologist.
Nair also wondered if the ministry’s pathologists had ever examined Adib’s body or even visited the scene. “It is extremely important that he did or else his evidence is purely guesswork and will be farcical.”
Nair said he was concerned by the objection raised by lawyers for the ministry and Adib’s family for the recall of HKL’s pathologist for further testimony.
“Clearly there is a strong case for the conducting officer to recall the HKL pathologists to give his views on the new opinion introduced. The lawyers shouldn’t fear this as it also gives them an opportunity to examine as well.”
But another former lawyer, Saiful Izham Ramli disagrees, saying it was not strange for the housing ministry to present testimony from its own pathologist. He said “the inquest is to determine Adib’s cause of death, it is not criminal proceedings whereby the rules and procedures are stricter,” he told FMT.
He also noted that the two ministries represented different interested parties. “The hospital represents the government and the other pathologist represents the housing and local government ministry which oversees the Fire and Rescue Department.”
Popular Posts - Last 7 days
-
‘Alas pintu’ dengan gambar Kaabah sebenarnya sejadah mini - AEON BiG April 13, 2024 Susulan penularan gambar yang mendakwa penjualan ‘alas ...
-
Screenshot of a video shared by the public of the incident at the Kuala Lumpur International Airport (KLIA) Arrival Hall 1 on Sunday. SEPANG...
-
MAN DIES AS HIS BMW I7 CRASHES AND BURNS, WOMAN FRIEND SERIOUSLY INJURED A man died while his woman friend was seriously injured when the ca...
-
Mohd Shuhaily said the suspect had two previous records for threats and another record for stealing and impersonating a civil servant. - BER...
-
Coach Maloney and FAM part ways after eight years Bernama Julai 13, 2022 The Football Association of Malaysia (FAM) has released under fir...
-
SUSPECT HAFIZUL HARAWI IN KLIA SHOOTING FLED IN A WHITE HONDA CITY WXU 5666 from the parking area at Level 2 of Block C, where he parked...
-
Malaysia detects 3,902 new COVID cases, 8 deaths Melissa Fernando ASTRO AWANi Julai 20, 2022 Malaysia detects 3,902 new COVID cases, 8 de...
-
The Kota Bharu Magistrate's Court here, today, allowed the suspect suspected of opening fire at the Kuala Lumpur International Airport...
-
Socso suspends RM423 million PenjanaKerjaya payments Bernama Julai 15, 2022 Socso chief executive officer Datuk Seri Dr Mohammed Azman Azi...
Popular Posts - Last 30 days
-
Saudi says application for 1444 H umrah visa opens from today Bernama Julai 14, 2022 The Ministry of Haj and Umrah of Saudi Arabia has ann...
-
Wan Saiful confirms he is no longer PTPTN chairman Bernama Julai 12, 2022 Bersatu Information chief Datuk Wan Saiful Wan Jan today confirm...
-
Kedah MB: ECK no longer part of Kulim airport project Bernama Julai 13, 2022 Muhammad Sanusi announced that the ECK Group of Companies (EC...
-
King presents appointment letters to four new envoys Bernama Julai 12, 2022 His Majesty presenting the letter of appointment to M'sian...
-
Following is BEST FBKL's selection of The Top Ramadan 2024 Buka Puasa Buffet's in Kuala Lumpur and the Klang Valley. We hope that y...
-
Naz Empire's defamation lawsuit against Awal Ashaari to go to trial as mediation fails Bernama Julai 12, 2022 The defamation lawsuit f...
-
Paris court grants Malaysia's application to suspend claims by purported heirs of Sultan Jamalul Kiram II Bernama Julai 13, 2022 Dr Wa...
-
‘Alas pintu’ dengan gambar Kaabah sebenarnya sejadah mini - AEON BiG April 13, 2024 Susulan penularan gambar yang mendakwa penjualan ‘alas ...
-
Maybank Singapore withdraws lawsuit against NFC chairman, children over housing loans Bernama Julai 12, 2022 Maybank Singapore Limited has...
Blog Archive
-
►
2023
(3771)
- December (311)
- November (322)
- October (286)
- September (288)
- August (365)
- July (349)
- June (372)
- May (316)
- April (279)
- March (301)
- February (245)
- January (337)
-
►
2022
(4309)
- December (352)
- November (422)
- October (288)
- September (281)
- August (347)
- July (303)
- June (335)
- May (406)
- April (341)
- March (371)
- February (390)
- January (473)
-
►
2021
(9030)
- December (636)
- November (647)
- October (809)
- September (797)
- August (880)
- July (894)
- June (747)
- May (780)
- April (580)
- March (629)
- February (643)
- January (988)
-
►
2020
(6800)
- December (819)
- November (698)
- October (832)
- September (729)
- August (548)
- July (558)
- June (615)
- May (394)
- April (368)
- March (453)
- February (439)
- January (347)
-
▼
2019
(4089)
- December (411)
- November (425)
- October (375)
- September (279)
- August (397)
- July (353)
- June (326)
- May (315)
- April (266)
- March (318)
- February (293)
- January (331)
-
►
2018
(4100)
- December (305)
- November (304)
- October (357)
- September (352)
- August (420)
- July (442)
- June (366)
- May (412)
- April (343)
- March (275)
- February (233)
- January (291)
-
►
2017
(3888)
- December (268)
- November (293)
- October (352)
- September (309)
- August (356)
- July (300)
- June (319)
- May (354)
- April (316)
- March (335)
- February (306)
- January (380)
-
►
2016
(4563)
- December (331)
- November (328)
- October (378)
- September (415)
- August (404)
- July (380)
- June (310)
- May (370)
- April (430)
- March (484)
- February (355)
- January (378)
-
►
2015
(4588)
- December (402)
- November (392)
- October (393)
- September (375)
- August (450)
- July (392)
- June (456)
- May (407)
- April (408)
- March (374)
- February (262)
- January (277)