Translate
26 April 2019
In argument about Federal Constitution and state rulers, lawyers agree with Dr M
In argument about Federal Constitution and state rulers, lawyers agree with Dr M
Julia Chan
Malay Mail26 April 2019
A general view of Istana Negara in Kuala Lumpur January 9, 2019. — Picture by Yusof Mat IsaMore
KOTA KINABALU, April 26 ― Constitutional lawyers seem to be in agreement that in a dispute between state rulers and the Constitution, the latter reigns supreme when it comes to the rule of law.
Lawyers polled by Malay Mail agree that while state constitutions used to play a big role in the state, Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad is right about the constitutional monarch not having executive power in the democracy.
However, the lawyers did point out that it was incorrect of Dr Mahathir to say that the state constitutions ― referring to Johor and Terengganu ― were “nullified”; they were just “modified” according to the new Federal Constitution then.
“The pre-Merdeka Johor Constitution gave wide powers to the monarch. But when we came together as a Federation, all state constitutions were streamlined in accordance to the principles of constitutional monarchy and parliamentary democracy,” said lawyer Lim Wei Jiet.
Both constitutions were modified in line with the 8th Schedule of the Federal Constitution which provides for the state constitution’s powers.
“One important change is that the Sultan must act on the advice of the mentri besar. No more absolute monarchy,” he said, adding that the constitutional monarchy system was reinforced vide several amendments to 8th Schedule in 1993.
“If you look at the Johor Constitution today, it still has many pre-Merdeka references, eg: Sultan Abu Bakar ― the famous monarch who promulgated the Johor Constitution.
“But remember, Article 71 of the Federal Constitution gives power to Parliament to discipline and keep states in check so they obey the 8th Schedule. If State Constitutions are amended to reassert more monarch powers beyond the 8th Schedule, Parliament can intervene and nullify such amendments,” said Liew.
“Long story short, the Johor Constitution is not ‘nullified’ ― but it is ‘modified’ substantially.
"The modification provides that, among others, the sultan must act in accordance to the advice of mentri besars,” said Liew.
Another lawyer, Ananth Surendra, also agreed that the interpretation of the state rulers’ powers would go to Dr Mahathir’s argument for constitutional democracy.
“Pre-independence, the state rulers had played a more influential role in governing the state where the ruler would preside over the executive council. The mentri besar would have to report back to the ruler and in some instances the ruler could even overrule the decision of the mentri besar.
“However, all this changed with the Federal Constitution. Article 71 expressly requires all states to ensure that the provisions in part 1 of the 8th Schedule are included in their respective constitutions,” he said.
If the states did not adopt the provisions in the 8th Schedule, Parliament had the power to enact laws to ensure that the said provisions are included or to remove the inconsistent provisions in the state constitutions.
However, all the states did adopt the provisions and one of the key provisions in the schedule is that the ruler must act on the advice of the state mentri besar.
“Thus, the ruler plays no role in the exercise of governmental power, except in the few scenarios provided for in the Federal Constitution,” he said.
Lawyer Nizam Bashir said that although the Federal Constitution was never intended to supercede state constitutions, and provides many guarantees to the state rulers, Parliament had the power to secure power if the state is in non compliance.
“In simpler words, while it is clear that state constitutions are not nullified when the Federal Constitution comes into effect, this is not to say that due regard is not to be given to the Federal Constitution. That much is clear from my reading of Article 71,” he said.
In the war of words between Dr Mahathir and the Johor monarchy, the Crown Prince Tunku Ismail Sultan Ibrahim had last night posted excerpts of the Federal Constitution on the rights of state rulers accorded by the country’s supreme law to the rulers.
Tunku Ismail cited Article 71(1), and 181 (1) which guarantees the right of a state ruler to enjoy and exercise his constitutional rights and privileges in accordance with the state’s constitution.
It was presumably in response to a blog post by Dr Mahathir who said the state constitutions of Johor and Terengganu, which came into effect in 1895 and 1911, were nullified once the new Federal Constitution was accepted by all the Malayan states in 1957.
Tensions first rose after the sudden resignation of former Johor Mentri Besar Datuk Osman Sapian due to royal interference and subsequently, Tunku Ismail insisted that the right of selecting a mentri besar was that of the Sultan’s.
Tension rose again recently with the Johor exco line-up which included three new members, despite Dr Mahathir’s announcement earlier that there would be no change to the line-up after the appointment of the new Mentri Besar Datuk Sahruddin Jamal.
Popular Posts - Last 7 days
-
Lyia Meta, the first Malaysian singer nominated in the Grammy Awards Astro Awani 11/11/2024 Lyia Meta continues to strengthen her position...
-
Priest stabbed in St Joseph's Church in Singapore 09/11/2024 SINGAPORE: A priest was injured in a knife attack during mass at St Josep...
-
Azlan Man mengaku tidak bersalah pertuduhan pilihan salah guna wang RM1.06 juta Bernama 12/11/2024 Bekas Menteri Besar Perlis Datuk Seri Az...
-
Dalam perkembangan terbaru dakwaan skandal rasuah, seorang pemberi maklumat mengeluarkan video tambahan, di samping lapan video perb...
-
Hasnah angkat sumpah jawatan Hakim Besar Malaya Bernama 12/11/2024 Datuk Seri Hasnah Mohammed Hashim mengangkat sumpah sebagai Hakim Besar M...
-
Tun Daim Zainuddin passes away 13/11/2024 KUALA LUMPUR: Former Finance Minister Tun Daim Zainuddin reportedly died this morning at the age ...
-
KWSP catat pendapatan pelaburan RM19.67 bilion pada suku ketiga Bernama 11/11/2024 Pendapatan pelaburan Kumpulan Wang Simpanan Pekerja (KWSP...
Popular Posts - Last 30 days
-
McDonald's E. coli crisis reveals why vegetable contamination is 'harder problem' than beef Reuters 26/10/2024 Fresh produce is ...
-
CNN CBS AP BBC US PRESIDENTIAL ELECTIONS LIVE RESULTS: https://edition.cnn.com/election/2024/results/president?elec...
-
Budget 2025: Govt allocates RM470 mil to empower women's participation in PMKS Bernama 18/10/2024 The government allocated RM470 million...
-
Kadar jangka pendek diunjurkan kekal kukuh disokong operasi BNM Bernama 04/11/2024 Hari ini, BNM akan menawarkan dua tender repo berbalik m...
-
Lyia Meta, the first Malaysian singer nominated in the Grammy Awards Astro Awani 11/11/2024 Lyia Meta continues to strengthen her position...
-
Seorang maut, 49 lagi jatuh sakit di AS akibat jangkitan E.Coli Astro Awani 23/10/2024 CDC memaklumkan semua individu ditemu bual melaporka...
-
The King of Spain was mocked, pelted with mud and eggs by flood victims Agency 04/11/2024 07:15 MYT King Felipe VI (with an umbrella) is pr...
-
PM Anwar hadir pada perlumbaan GP Malaysia 2024 Bernama 03/11/2024 Anwar (dua, kiri) melambaikan tangan kepada para penonton ketika hadir pa...
Blog Archive
-
▼
2019
(4089)
-
▼
Apr 2019
(266)
- A former officer to an ex-minister has been remand...
- A former special officer to an ex-minister has bee...
- RM1.9 billion in Najib's Account purportedly a don...
- The High Court has dismissed Datuk Seri Najib Raza...
- : A total of 173 child sexual abusers have been pu...
- Video of Controversial Muslim preacher Zamri Vinot...
- Gunman in synagogue shooting identified
- Dr Mahathir comments on a video of Tunku Ismail as...
- A Brazilian model died Saturday after collapsing o...
- Zakir Naik associate arrested in Perlis for insult...
- FORUM STATUT ROM KECOH, UNGKAP PERKATAAN ‘BODOH’,
- AG: Rome Statute cannot be used against constituti...
- Former diplomat Datuk Noor Farida Ariffin said the...
- Air Mata Komander Tumpah unit khas STAFOC Dibubarkan
- Comedian becomes Ukraine President, Malaysia?
- Dr Mahathir gets first-hand AI experience with sel...
- Man charged for splashing paint on mosque’s door
- A snatch thief was caught after failing to yank a ...
- Five-cornered fight for Sandakan parliament seat
- Zahran Hashim Sri Lanka bombers' mentor is believe...
- 15 people, including six children, were discovered...
- Entertainment lawyer Samuel Seow has made a police...
- EPL | Liverpool 5 - 0 Huddersfield Town | Astro Su...
- Senior Federal Court judge Azahar Mohamed is likel...
- Chinese President Xi Jinping met with Prime Minist...
- The High Court will decide on Monday (April 29) if...
- Datuk Seri CEO, company advisor remanded four days...
- In argument about Federal Constitution and state r...
- Najib Razak's lawyer today claimed that documents ...
- Vietnamese woman on the hook for murdering the hal...
- Consumer Claims Tribunal to raise maximum fine for...
- Wang Kelian RCI: SB officer identifies Malaysian c...
- FGV Holdings Bhd has denied a news report today st...
- Police in Sri Lanka are still looking for Zahran H...
- Tun Mahathir In China, Visits Huawei On His First ...
- Muhyiddin: Good gesture, but Sultan must stop inte...
- Anwar Says "PM Tun Mahathir Interpretation of The ...
- Lim Guan Eng; Kerajaan akan terus memantau prestas...
- Isu Ustaz PU Abu cerai isteri hamil, kahwin janda ...
- Sports Minister Syed Saddiq reveals TMJ wanted Man...
- Les’ Copaque Production THE Upin & Ipin producer m...
- English Premier League | Manchester United 0 - 2 M...
- Prime Minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad will be in ...
- Deputy Home Minister Datuk Mohd Azis Jamman was in...
- Sports Minister's Priorities All Screwed! ..... so...
- Former IGP Tan Sri Khalid Abu Bakar gave specific ...
- Almost RM3.3 million was diverted from one of Datu...
- Najib Razak had previously appointed SRC Internati...
- TMJ posted on social media excerpts of the Federal...
- The former Perlis Deputy Police Chief today denied...
- Upgrading works at Sungai Selangor Phase 2 Water T...
- IGP Says he was aware about talk of terrorist link...
- Polis Negeri Sembilan terima laporan 217 kes tipu,...
- Deputy Comm Datuk Kamarulzaman has taken over as B...
- Tun Dr Mahathir upset as Details has emerged indi...
- PERANG TERBUKA? VIDEO KHAS TMJ TUJU KEPADA SYED SA...
- Viral CCTV footage shows suspected suicide bomber ...
- Indonesian Elections: Pollster quick counts show i...
- Petition calling for justice over Adelina's death ...
- English Premier League Roundup | 22 April 2019 | M...
- Tensed PPBM meeting over Johor exco line-up ends w...
- Najib Razak paid RM300,000 to a private consulting...
- New DPM, Singapore’s Finance Minister Heng Swee Ke...
- Klang Valley residents prepare for 4-day water dis...
- CID Head was told to stop investigations following...
- Teenage girl allegedly forced by father into sex w...
- The short selling activities for the shares of Eko...
- A Former lawyer has claimed trial at the Sessions ...
- SEASONAL fruit sellers, especially those selling d...
- Stolen Bukit Aman narcotic chief's car discovered ...
- Tun Dr Mahathir; Sultan has no say in new Exco by ...
- Three Johor Exco assemblymen have been sworn as ne...
- Sri Lanka Suicide Bombers Attack on Churches and F...
- Tun Dr Mahathir: I don’t have enough time
- AME 2019 | Senarai Pemenang Anugerah Meletop Era 2...
- Sri Lanka Easter Sunday Suicide Bombers Attack - m...
- Public Demands Why AG Dropped Charges against Ind...
- Former Johor exco member Datuk Abdul Latif Bandi h...
- Comedian Kojo gets Simon's GOLDEN BUZZER ON Britai...
- INCREDIBLE Akshat Singh dances his way to Ant & De...
- English Premier League Roundup | 21 April 2019 | M...
- Unbecoming and adversarial” for lawyers of the Hou...
- BLACKPINK - Kill This Love Video Gets almost 230 m...
- DATO M.NASIR turun Bukit Bintang KL nyanyi lagu GE...
- Dr M on succession plan - NST EXCLUSIVE
- A surprise singer to the song 'Hijau' when veteran...
- Datuk Zamri Man will be removed as Ipoh mayor for ...
- The MACC have arrested a further 22 enforcement of...
- Anina Saadudin has drawn public ire, she should be...
- A General Operations Force (GOF) officer involved ...
- Penyelia kedai emas di pasar raya di Seri Kembang...
- A punter has won Magnum 4D’s second-highest Jackpo...
- Najib Razak lost his cool when he yelled at polic...
- Malaysian ‘dangdut’ singer feels the wrath of cons...
- Tun Mahathir and Communications Minister Take Driv...
- Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad today said the government ...
- Subang Runway Crash : Plane Received Clearance to ...
- Tun Mahathir on Time magazine’s 100 Most Influenti...
- The pump price of RON97 petrol will go up by 12 se...
- The candidate to replace Tan Sri Richard Malanjum ...
-
▼
Apr 2019
(266)